Being labeled the 'worst' wrestling announcer of 2025 is a tough pill to swallow, but that's exactly what happened to WWE NXT's Booker T, according to readers of Dave Meltzer’s Wrestling Observer Newsletter. But here's where it gets controversial... While Booker T joined the ranks of Pat McAfee, Michael Cole, Vic Joseph, and Tony Schiavone in the top five, his response to the criticism is anything but typical. In a recent podcast, Booker T addressed the vote with a mix of self-awareness and unapologetic authenticity.
'I’m not your cup of tea,' he admitted, acknowledging that his style might not appeal to everyone. And this is the part most people miss... Booker T didn’t shy away from discussing the elephant in the room: his unique voice and background. 'I talk street,' he explained, emphasizing that his commentary brings a distinct flavor to the booth—one that’s rooted in his experiences and identity. He even drew a clever analogy, comparing his style to gumbo: 'Somebody like Meltzer, he’s probably never had a bowl of gumbo in his life. If he had, it was chicken gumbo.'
While he didn’t explicitly play the race card, Booker T subtly highlighted the lack of diversity among wrestling commentators, pointing out that there aren’t many Black voices in the industry. 'I can’t talk like Vic Joseph or Michael Cole—none of these guys. I can’t do it. I’m just me,' he declared. This raises a thought-provoking question: Is the criticism of Booker T’s style a matter of personal preference, or does it reflect deeper biases in the wrestling world?
What’s undeniable is that Booker T has a loyal fanbase. 'A lot of people like it,' he asserted, and his confidence in his authenticity is hard to ignore. His response isn’t just a defense—it’s a celebration of individuality in an industry that often values conformity. But here’s the real question: Does wrestling commentary need to sound a certain way, or is there room for more diverse voices like Booker T’s? Let’s hear your thoughts in the comments—do you think Booker T deserves the 'worst' label, or is his style exactly what the wrestling world needs?
